Not All Shoes Go With Pencil Skirts, But These 6 Definitely Do

Ava Gilchrist
It's official: pencil skirts are back. Naturally, our next step is to determine the shoes to wear with pencil skirts, especially if you haven't worn one in a few decades. (If you're yet to brave this silhouette's return, why not refresh yourself on how to wear a pencil skirt before perusing the footwear department?)
After retreating out of the limelight for the past few years, the sexy style is back hanging on the hips of those in the know. Unlike its '00s ancestors, 2025's pencil skirts look undeniably fresh. Void of bookish, stuffy or drab connotations, this season's iterations utilise all of the learnings of yesteryear to create figure-hugging styles that top the charts for elegance and style. Wondering how to look classy? This is it.
So, how are today's connoisseurs pairing pencil skirts with the right footwear to make the shape feel modern and not matronly? Ushered in by the resurgence of the '90s and Y2K fashion , the trend, which was formally the reserve of the office, has looped back and brought with it fishnet tights and sharp kitten heels.
You might remember from the first time around that the skin-tight skirt isn't the easiest to style. Trickier than a flowing maxi or a cute mini, a fitted pencil skirt looks amazing with certain shoe styles and less captivating with others. (See: trainers.)
I've done the hard work for you and figured out how to make it work. Read on and discover the best pencil skirt outfits and their ideal correlating footwear options so you'l never ask what shoes to wear with pencil skirts again.
What Shoes Do You Wear With Pencil Skirts?
Consider this your guide to the ultimate 2025 shoe capsule wardrobe specifically curated for styles to wear with pencil skirts. As pencil skirts are quite fitted to the body, the best shoes to wear with pencil skirts are those that enhance the structure of the look. T
hese styles are usually polished like pointed-toe flat shoes, a sleek boot or an elevated kitten heel. Alternatively, soften the rigid fit with round-toe shoes like Mary Janes, ballet flats or penny loafers.
Historically, pencil skirts have been omitted from the canon of chunky shoes. It's rare we see a sporty trainer or buckled boot with the pencil skirt, but any longline shoe options can certainly balance out the formality of the garment.
6 Styles of Shoes to Wear With Pencil Skirts
1. Pencil Skirt + Knee-High Boots
Style Notes: While we linger in this lukewarm spring, style your slim-fitting skirt with tights and knee-high boots—additional layers up top are optional. To get the proportions right, shop a pencil skirt that falls below the knee or lower, and style with either flat or heeled boots for the ultimate anti-trainer outfit.
Shop the Look:
This deep espresso shade is a major colour trend this year.
Style with a skirt that falls just below the knee or your favourite mini.
2. Pencil Skirt + Pointed-Toe Flats
Style Notes: Copy the cool girls and swap your heels for flats. Sharp, pointed-toe styles will work to elongate the body for a chic '90s touch, making it an ideal shoe to wear with pencil skirts as it plays into the tailored details of the piece.
Shop the Look:
Tory Burch's pierced ballet flats were a standout style at her Spring/Summer 2023 collection before becoming a mainstay at her New York Fashion Week last September. Fittingly, the eponymous designer styled hers both on the runway and in the front row with a pencil skirt, too.
3. Pencil Skirt + Mary Janes
Style Notes: For a more casual look, round-toe shoes like Mary Janes can help temper the rigidness of pencil skirts. I love how this pencil skirt is also made from suede and styled with a matching suede jacket, as the soft texture helps acheive a more lived-in effect.
Shop the Look:
Dress this down with a white T-shirt or up with a silk blouse.
The double strap feels like the footwear version of the dual or unnecessary belt trend that Bella Hadid helped pioneer.
4. Pencil Skirt + Kitten Heels
Style Notes: One of my favourite combinations is a pencil skirt with kitten heels. This pairing works with any length of skirt, and you can add tights in the winter or go bare-legged when the sun comes out.
Shop the Look:
In my opinion, short kitten heels make for the perfect party shoes.
5. Pencil Skirt + Strappy Sandals
Style Notes: This tried-and-true pairing is the easiest way to enter party season with style. Dress this up with a backless top and re-wear it with a slim knit.
Shop the Look:
If you love satin trousers, you'll adore this satin pencil skirt.
Black strappy heels are the wardrobe hero you didn't know you needed.
6. Pencil Skirt + Heeled Mules
Style Notes: If you've been hesitant to invest in this style because of their simplicity, consider the best shoes to wear with pencil skirts to be heeled mules, then. The raised sole brings a touch of primness and refinement to unfussy silhouettes, such is the case with this monochromatic look here.
Shop the Look:
This flared maxi skirt brings a bit more dimension and movement to your look.
Take it from Hailey Bieber, heeled mules are a staple.
Natalie Munro is Who What Wear UK’s news writer and has worked in the fashion industry since she graduated with a degree in Journalism from the University of the Arts London. Natalie’s experience in the industry spans journalistic and styling roles that have seen her work for publications including British Vogue, Conde Nast Traveller, Vogue Ukraine, AnOther Magazine and Elle UK.
With an interest in uncovering the latest fashion trends, Natalie takes a leading role in identifying news for Who What Wear UK. Reporting on a daily basis, Natalie focuses on trends on and off the runway, as well as street style and celebrity fashion. Natalie also creates content for Who What Wear’s social channels including TikTok and Instagram on a weekly basis.
- Ava GilchristSEO Writer
-
Jamie Mizrahi's World: The Celeb Stylist's Favorite Red Carpet Look, Most Worth-It Shoe, and Album She Listens to on Repeat
A modern-day style expert.
By Allyson Payer
-
How Everyone Will Be Wearing Their Non–Skinny Jeans This Spring
Here's your outfit inspiration.
By Michelle Scanga
-
Suddenly, Women With The Row Style Are Breaking This Fashion Rule
You should too.
By Nikki Chwatt
-
We're Fashion Editors—Everything We Saw, Wore, Did, and Ate During NYFW
Let's dive in.
By Anna LaPlaca
-
Jenna Lyons's World: Her Go-To Red Lipstick, Her Latest Eyewear Collab, and the J.Crew Pieces She Still Wears Today
A true fashion icon.
By Judith Jones
-
Not Into Trends? Renée Zellweger's Winter Outfit Combo Is 100% Classic
Just as you are.
By Drew Elovitz
-
Emma Chamberlain's World: Her Warby Parker Collab, Two-Phone Rule, and Spiciest Fashion Takes
"I just want to bring the most joy to people."
By Anna LaPlaca
-
4 Anti-Trend Outfits I Spot Every Time I'm in Europe
Classic looks that are always in style.
By Natalie Cantell